Home / AVO / Grievous Bodily Harm: Penalties and Defence Options

Grievous Bodily Harm: Penalties and Defence Options

Table of Contents

Need a Lawyer?

how to prove assault | Justice Family Lawyers

Written by Hayder Shkara

If you have been charged with grievous bodily harm in New South Wales, or someone in your family has, it’s not a minor charge. Grievous bodily harm (GBH) means really serious harm. In NSW it is charged under the Crimes Act 1900, mainly as section 33 (causing it with intent) or section 35 (causing it recklessly). The maximum penalties are serious, up to 25 years for the most serious offence. But the sentence a court actually hands down depends on which offence is charged and the facts of the case, not the maximum.

This page covers the law as it applies in New South Wales. Take it as general information, not advice on your own matter, and get proper advice before you make any decision about a charge.

What grievous bodily harm means in NSW

Grievous bodily harm is a legal term for really serious harm to the body. It is a higher threshold than a cut or a bruise.

The Crimes Act 1900 spells out part of what counts. Under the definition, grievous bodily harm includes any permanent or serious disfiguring, the destruction of a fetus (other than in a medical procedure), and any grievous bodily disease. Beyond that list, the courts apply the plain meaning, it’s harm that is really serious. Think along the lines of a fractured skull, a broken bone, a serious internal injury, or a wound that leaves lasting damage.

Grievous bodily harm is defined in section 4 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW).

You do not have to work out the exact label yourself. The point to hold onto is that the prosecution has to prove the harm was serious, and how serious it was shapes both the charge and the penalty.

The two main offences and their penalties

Almost every grievous bodily harm charge in NSW falls under one of two sections of the Crimes Act 1900. The difference between them is your state of mind at the time.

Section 33, causing grievous bodily harm with intent. This is the most serious version. It applies where you wounded a person or caused really serious harm and you meant to cause that serious harm. The maximum penalty is 25 years imprisonment.

See section 33 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW).

Section 35, recklessly causing grievous bodily harm or wounding. This applies where you did not intend the serious harm, but you went ahead knowing your actions could cause some harm. Section 35 has four versions, and the maximum penalty steps up when the offence is committed “in company”, meaning alongside other people.

See section 35 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW).

Here is how the offences and their maximum penalties compare.

Offence Section Maximum penalty Standard non-parole period Court
Wounding or causing grievous bodily harm with intent s 33 25 years 7 years District Court
Recklessly causing grievous bodily harm in company s 35(1) 14 years 5 years District or Local Court
Recklessly causing grievous bodily harm s 35(2) 10 years 4 years District or Local Court
Reckless wounding in company s 35(3) 10 years 4 years District or Local Court
Reckless wounding s 35(4) 7 years 3 years District or Local Court

Sources: NSW Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions and the NSW Sentencing Bench Book.

You will notice the “standard non-parole period” column. That term trips a lot of people up, so let me be clear about what it is. A standard non-parole period is the reference point a court uses for an offence that sits in the middle of the range of seriousness. It is not a mandatory minimum, and it is not the sentence you are guaranteed to get. It is a guidepost the judge starts from and then moves up or down based on the facts.

Grievous bodily harm, wounding and actual bodily harm

These three terms get used loosely, but in NSW they sit at different levels, and the level decides the charge.

  • Actual bodily harm is the lower tier, which is harm that is serious but not permanent, such as bruising, scratches or minor lasting marks. It is charged under section 59, with a maximum of 5 years.
  • Wounding means the skin is broken through both layers, the outer and the inner. A cut that breaks the skin can be a wounding even if it is not, on its own, really serious harm.
  • Grievous bodily harm is the top of the ladder: really serious harm, as set out above.

Where your matter sits on that ladder is often the first thing worth looking at, because moving a charge down a rung can change everything about the penalty you face.

Which court hears a grievous bodily harm charge

The court matters, because it sets the ceiling on the penalty.

A section 33 charge is strictly indictable. That means it is serious enough that it can only be finalised in the District Court.

A section 35 charge is what is called a Table 1 offence. It can be dealt with in either the District Court or the Local Court. If it stays in the Local Court, the maximum penalty a magistrate can impose drops to 2 years, regardless of the higher maximum in the section. That is why the court a charge ends up in can matter as much as the charge itself.

Defences to a grievous bodily harm charge

Being charged is not the same as being guilty. The prosecution has to prove every part of the offence beyond reasonable doubt, including that it was you, that the harm was serious, and that you had the required state of mind. If they cannot, the charge does not stand. On top of that, there are recognised defences.

Self-defence. This applies if you believed your conduct was necessary to defend yourself or someone else, and what you did was a reasonable response to the situation as you saw it. The important part is who has to prove it: once there is evidence you were acting in self-defence, the prosecution has to disprove it beyond reasonable doubt to secure a conviction, not the other way around.

Self-defence is set out in section 418 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW).

Duress. This applies where you acted because of a genuine, serious threat and any reasonable person in your position would have done the same.

Necessity. This applies where you acted to avoid a greater and imminent harm, and your response was proportionate to the danger.

Whether any of these fits depends on the evidence, and that is a call to make with a lawyer early, not on your own.

What shapes the sentence

If there is a conviction, the sentence is not read off a chart. A court weighs a range of factors, and this is where two matters with the same charge can end up in very different places.

The main things that move the outcome are the offence charged (intent under section 33 is treated far more seriously than recklessness under section 35), the seriousness of the injury, and how the offence happened. The standard non-parole period sits in the background as a guidepost for a mid-range offence.

Then there are the factors that can bring a sentence down. An early guilty plea is treated as a mitigating factor, and so are genuine remorse, prior good character, and steps towards rehabilitation. The outcome is not a single fixed number. Depending on the facts, it can range from a term of full-time imprisonment, to a sentence served in the community, through to a non-conviction order in the right case.

How a victim impact statement is used

In a grievous bodily harm matter, the victim can give the court a victim impact statement at the sentencing stage. It sets out, in the victim’s own words, how the offence affected them physically, emotionally and financially.

It is worth understanding what this does and does not do. The statement does not decide the charge, and it is not evidence of whether the offence happened. It comes in after a finding or plea of guilt, and it informs how the court views the harm caused when it sets the sentence. In a case that turns on how serious the harm was, that can carry real weight. It is one of the reasons the sentencing stage deserves as much preparation as the question of guilt.

How police and forensic evidence shapes a case

A grievous bodily harm case is usually built on evidence gathered early: medical records and scans that describe the injury, forensic and photographic evidence from the scene, and statements from the victim and any witnesses.

That evidence does more than describe what happened. It goes to the two things the prosecution has to nail down: how serious the harm actually was, and your state of mind. Medical evidence is often what decides whether an injury crosses the line into grievous bodily harm, or sits below it as actual bodily harm, which is a different charge with a much lower maximum. And the surrounding evidence, what was said and done, is what the prosecution uses to argue intent under section 33 versus recklessness under section 35.

This is where having a lawyer involved early counts. The sooner the medical and forensic material is reviewed, the sooner you know whether the charge fits the evidence or whether there is room to challenge it.

Grievous bodily harm charges often come alongside domestic and personal violence matters, including an AVO. If that is your situation, it is worth understanding how the two run together, and what breaching an AVO can add to an already serious position.

Getting advice early

A grievous bodily harm charge is serious, and the earlier you get advice the more room there is to shape what happens next. Whether the goal is challenging the charge, getting it moved down a rung, or preparing properly for sentencing, the work starts with understanding exactly what you are facing.

My team and I handle AVO and domestic violence matters alongside our family law work, and we will walk you through your options clearly, with no pressure. Book a free discovery call or phone us on 1300 614 732, and we will help you work out your next step.

Frequently Asked Questions

Grievous bodily harm in NSW means really serious harm to the body. The Crimes Act 1900 includes any permanent or serious disfiguring, the destruction of a foetus, and any grievous bodily disease, and the courts apply the plain meaning of really serious harm on top of that. It is a higher threshold than a minor cut or bruise.

Actual bodily harm is the lower level: harm that is serious but not permanent, such as bruising or minor lasting marks, charged under section 59 with a maximum of 5 years. Grievous bodily harm is really serious harm, and it carries far higher maximum penalties.

The maximum depends on the offence. Causing grievous bodily harm with intent under section 33 carries up to 25 years imprisonment. Recklessly causing grievous bodily harm under section 35 carries up to 10 years, or up to 14 years if it was done in company.

Not automatically. A court weighs the offence charged, the seriousness of the injury, and factors such as an early guilty plea and remorse. Depending on the facts, outcomes range from full-time imprisonment, to a sentence served in the community, through to a non-conviction order in the right case.

The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that it was you, that the harm was really serious, and that you had the required state of mind: intent for a section 33 charge, or recklessness for a section 35 charge. If any part is not proven, the charge does not stand.

A section 33 charge is strictly indictable and is heard in the District Court. A section 35 charge is a Table 1 offence and can be dealt with in the District Court or the Local Court, where the maximum penalty is capped at 2 years.

A conviction for grievous bodily harm goes on your criminal record, and because it is a serious charge, a conviction is the usual outcome where the case is proven. It is not automatic in every case, though. Sentencing outcomes range from full-time imprisonment through to a non-conviction order in the right case, and where a court decides not to record a conviction, no criminal record follows. Which way it goes turns on the offence charged and the facts.

Hayder

Hayder Shkara

Principal of Justice Family Lawyers, Hayder Shkara specialises in complex parenting and property family law matters. He is based in Sydney and holds a Bachelor of Law and Bachelor of Communications from UTS.
Scroll to Top

Book Consultation

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)