When dealing with family law disputes in Australia, you may come across the phrase “without prejudice save as to costs.”
This legal term might seem complicated, but understanding it can make a big difference in your case. In simple terms, “without prejudice save as to costs” means that any offer or communication made under this phrase cannot be used as evidence in court unless the court is deciding who should pay legal costs.
It’s a way to protect negotiation efforts while still encouraging fair settlement offers.
Let’s break down this legal concept and explore what it means for family law cases in Australia.
What Does “Without Prejudice Save as to Costs” Mean in Australian Family Law?
The phrase “without prejudice save as to costs” is commonly used in family law when parties are negotiating a settlement. The term “without prejudice” means that anything said or written during settlement discussions cannot be used against you if the case goes to court.
This protection encourages open and honest negotiations without fear of those discussions being used as evidence later on.
However, when you add “save as to costs”, it creates an important exception. If the case ends up in court, the judge can look at these offers after deciding the main issues to determine who should pay legal costs.
This is particularly important if one party has made a reasonable offer to settle and the other party has refused it. In such cases, the court might order the party who refused the offer to pay more of the legal costs.
In family law, this phrase is often used during property settlement discussions or when negotiating parenting arrangements. It is a powerful tool because it helps the parties negotiate freely while still providing a safeguard if the case proceeds to a hearing.
How Does “Without Prejudice Save as to Costs” Impact My Family Law Case?
Understanding the impact of a “without prejudice save as to costs” offer can help you make informed decisions in your family law case. Here’s how it works:
Encourages Settlement Negotiations: By using this phrase, you can make offers without worrying that they will be used against you if the case goes to court. This allows for more open discussions and a better chance of reaching a fair settlement.
Potential Cost Consequences: If your case does go to court, the judge may look at any “without prejudice save as to costs” offers made by both parties. If you made a reasonable offer that was rejected, the judge could decide that the other party should pay more of the legal costs.
This is because the court wants to encourage parties to settle disputes early and avoid unnecessary litigation.
Risk of Refusing a Reasonable Offer: If you refuse a reasonable offer made “without prejudice save as to costs”, you could end up paying a significant amount of legal costs. This is why it’s important to carefully consider any offers made under this phrase and seek legal advice before rejecting them.
In family law cases, the costs can add up quickly. Using “without prejudice save as to costs” offers effectively can help minimise legal expenses and reduce the stress of lengthy court battles.
Also Read: 7 Effective Tips for Negotiating a Property Settlement
When Can Offers Marked “Without Prejudice Save as to Costs” Be Used in Court?
Normally, any offer made during settlement discussions is considered “without prejudice”, meaning it cannot be shown to the judge until after the case is decided.
This rule helps keep negotiations private and encourages both parties to be honest during settlement talks. However, when the offer is made “without prejudice save as to costs”, there is an exception.
In this case, the offer remains private until the court has made its decision on the main issues, like property division or parenting arrangements. Once the court has given its judgement, it can look at the “without prejudice save as to costs” offers to decide who should pay the legal costs.
For example, if you made a fair offer to settle the dispute early, but the other party refused, the judge might decide that the other party should pay more of the legal fees. This is because they chose to continue the litigation instead of accepting a reasonable settlement.
It’s important to remember that the court will only consider these offers after making its final decision. This means your offers won’t influence the judge’s decision on the main issues of the case, but they could impact the final costs order.
Also Read: What is a Parenting Plan?
Can a “Without Prejudice Save as to Costs” Offer Influence Legal Costs Orders?
Yes, a “without prejudice save as to costs” offer can have a significant impact on legal costs orders in family law cases. Here’s how:
Encouraging Reasonable Behaviour: The purpose of allowing the court to consider these offers is to encourage both parties to act reasonably during negotiations.
If one party makes a fair offer and the other party refuses it without good reason, the court may order the refusing party to pay a higher share of the legal costs.
Reducing Legal Expenses: By making a “without prejudice save as to costs” offer, you are showing the court that you tried to settle the matter reasonably and avoid a costly court hearing. This can be beneficial if you want to limit your exposure to legal fees, especially if the other party was unwilling to compromise.
Avoiding Penalties: If you receive a “without prejudice save as to costs” offer and reject it without a strong reason, you could end up paying more legal costs. This is because the court may view your refusal as unreasonable, especially if the offer was close to what the court ultimately decides.
In family law, costs orders are rare unless one party has acted unreasonably. Using “without prejudice save as to costs” offers effectively can help demonstrate that you acted reasonably and may protect you from paying excessive legal fees.
How Should I Make a “Without Prejudice Save as to Costs” Offer in Family Law Proceedings?
Making a “without prejudice save as to costs” offer requires careful consideration. Here are some key tips to keep in mind:
Be Clear and Specific: Make sure your offer clearly states that it is made “without prejudice save as to costs”. This phrase must be included to ensure that the offer has the intended legal protection.
Put It in Writing: Always make these offers in writing. This provides a clear record of the terms of the offer and can be presented to the court if needed during a costs hearing.
Seek Legal Advice: It’s a good idea to consult with a family lawyer before making or responding to a “without prejudice save as to costs” offer. They can help you understand whether the offer is reasonable and guide you on the best approach for your case.
Make a Genuine Offer: The offer should be reasonable and reflect a fair compromise. If the offer is too low or unrealistic, it’s unlikely to be effective, and the court may not look favourably upon it.
Consider Timing: Timing can be crucial. Making an offer early in the proceedings can demonstrate to the court that you tried to settle the matter from the outset, which can be beneficial in costs hearings.
Why It Matters: Maximising the Benefits of Settlement Offers
Making a “without prejudice save as to costs” offer is a strategic move in family law cases. It allows you to negotiate freely while protecting your interests if the case ends up in court. By following these guidelines, you can use this tool effectively to increase your chances of a fair outcome and potentially save on legal costs.
Understanding the meaning of “without prejudice save as to costs” in Australia is essential for anyone involved in family law disputes. It encourages parties to negotiate fairly and provides a safeguard when it comes to legal costs.
Remember, this legal tool can be powerful when used correctly, but it’s always best to get professional advice to ensure you make the most of it.
Dealing With A Family Law Matter?
If you want to learn more about your options, Justice Family Lawyers is here to help. Contact our expert lawyers today for tailored advice on your case and see how we can support you in achieving a fair resolution.
