Can An AVO Be Appealed: Know the 4 Possible Grounds
Once the court makes a final verdict, the next question a defendant must ask is: Can an AVO be appealed?
Yes, it is possible to appeal an Apprehended Violence Order (AVO) in Australia.
Both the person against whom the order is issued (the defendant) and the person who requested the order (the applicant) have the right to appeal the court’s decision regarding an AVO.
On What Grounds Can An AVO Be Appealed?
Depending on the specifics of the case and the state or territory’s laws and regulations, an Apprehended Violence Order (AVO) may be appealed on various grounds. Listed below are some common grounds for appealing an AVO:
An Error of Law: It indicates that the magistrate made an erroneous legal determination or interpretation during the initial hearing.
This may involve a misunderstanding of the applicable law or the application of the incorrect legal standard.
Against the Weight of Evidence: This indicates that the court’s decision did not accurately reflect the evidence presented.
In other words, the evidence presented in the case was insufficient to support the verdict.
Unreasonable or Cannot be Supported by Evidence:
This indicates that the court’s decision could have been more logical and could not be supported by the evidence.
This might occur if the decision was based on speculation or conjecture rather than solid evidence.
Procedural Fairness: This could be applicable if there were significant problems with how the hearing was conducted.
For instance, if a party needed to be afforded an adequate opportunity to present their case or if the court displayed bias.
Can An AVO Be Appealed, And How Does The Process Work?
Can an AVO be appealed, and how to apply for one?
The process can vary slightly between states and territories, but in general, the following steps are involved:
File a Notice of Appeal: This is the official document that begins the appeals process. It must be filed with the court within a certain amount following the AVO decision (usually within 28 days). This notice should outline the appeal’s grounds (reasons).
Prepare for the Appeal Hearing: The appellant (the individual appealing the AVO) and their legal counsel must prepare arguments supporting the appeal.
This may involve collecting additional evidence, drafting legal arguments, and arranging for witnesses to testify.
The Appeal Hearing: During the appeal hearing, the appellant presents their case to a judge. This is not a retrial of the original case but a review of the original verdict and the procedure that led to it.
The judge will determine if the magistrate made a legal error or if the decision was contrary to the weight of the evidence during the initial hearing.
Decision: After considering the arguments and evidence, the judge will decide. The judge can uphold the original decision (dismissing the appeal), reverse the original decision (allowing the appeal), or modify the original decision.
Further Appeals: If the appellant is still unsatisfied with the decision after the appeal hearing, they may have the option to appeal to a higher court.
However, this is usually only possible in certain circumstances, and additional legal advice would be necessary.
Is There A Time Limit To File For An AVO Appeal?
Can an AVO be appealed, and is there a time limit?
Yes, Australia typically has a time limit for appealing an Apprehended Violence Order (AVO) decision.
Generally, an appeal must be filed within 28 days of the court issuing the original decision. However, the exact time limit can vary by jurisdiction.
Suppose the appeal is filed within a different timeframe. In that case, it is still possible to do so.
However, the appellant (the person filing the appeal) must typically seek the court’s permission and provide an acceptable explanation for the delay.
Can An AVO Be Appealed?
Get the expert legal help you need from Justice Family Lawyers.
Our experienced team understands the complexities of AVO appeals and is committed to providing comprehensive and compassionate support.
We can help guide you through each step of the appeal process, ensuring your rights are upheld. Don’t navigate this legal journey alone – reach out to Justice Family Lawyers today, and let’s explore your options together. Time is critical, so contact us immediately!
Principal of Justice Family Lawyers, Hayder specialises in complex parenting and property family law matters. He is based in Sydney and holds a Bachelor of Law and Bachelor of Communications from UTS.